MagnaCut and Elmax are both premium stainless steels that consistently show up on shortlists for high-end knives, and on paper they’re closer to each other than either is to most other steels on this site. Here’s where the real differences actually show up.
The numbers, side by side
Every figure on this page has a named source. Crucible and Uddeholm numbers come from the manufacturers' datasheets. The 0 to 10 ratings, the saltwater tests and the CATRA chart are Larrin Thomas's at Knife Steel Nerds. Thomas designed MagnaCut and the Crucible sheet is the maker's own, so read the MagnaCut column with that in mind. The 1 to 5 scores in the table above are this site's shorthand, not Thomas's scale. MagnaCut figures are for the original Crucible-made steel; the question about Crucible below explains the update.
| Measure | MagnaCut | Elmax |
|---|
| Carbon and chromium, % by weight | 1.15 C, 10.7 Cr | 1.7 C, 18.0 Cr |
| Chromium carbide in the hardened steel | None (Crucible) | A large share of its carbide (Thomas) |
| Toughness rating, 0 to 10 (Thomas, about 59 to 62 HRC) | 7 | 4 |
| Edge retention rating, 0 to 10 (Thomas) | 5 | 5.5 |
| Corrosion rating, 0 to 10 (Thomas) | 9.5 | 8 |
| 1% saltwater spray, 72 hours (Thomas) | No rust | Rust spots |
| Austenitize, target (range) | 2050°F (1950–2200°F) | 1980°F (1920–2010°F) |
| Temper | 2 × 2 hours at 350°F | 2 × 2 hours minimum, 480°F or higher preferred |
| Hardness from the maker's recipe | 61.5 HRC (plate or oil quench), 62 HRC (dry ice or liquid nitrogen); aim 60–63 HRC | 56–58 HRC at the 480°F and 980°F tempers (60–61 HRC as quenched, before tempering); a cryogenic treatment, which Uddeholm permits, adds 1–2 HRC (about 57–60 HRC by our sum, not an Uddeholm table value) |
Questions makers ask
Is MagnaCut really tougher than Elmax, and by how much?
Yes. Thomas rates MagnaCut 7 out of 10 for toughness and Elmax 4, both at roughly 59 to 62 HRC. Crucible's own Charpy table lists MagnaCut at 38 ft-lbs at 62.5 HRC and 30 ft-lbs at 64 HRC. Elmax is not in that table, but the powder stainless steels that are, CPM S35VN at 25 ft-lbs, CPM S90V at 17 and CPM 20CV at 15, all sit below MagnaCut. Thomas explains the gap: early high-chromium powder steels such as Elmax have a coarse structure because a large share of their carbide is chromium carbide, and MagnaCut has none. He adds that toughness works on a log scale, so going from 5 to 10 ft-lbs is about the same gain as going from 10 to 20.
In practice that means MagnaCut can carry a thinner edge before it chips. Crucible's sheet says the same in its own words: fine cutting knives can have thinner edges with less risk of chipping, and the steel is especially good for bigger blades.
Does Elmax hold an edge longer?
By a modest margin at the same hardness. Thomas rates Elmax 5.5 and MagnaCut 5 for edge retention. In his CATRA chart, where every steel is sharpened the same way, at the same edge angle, and cuts abrasive cards, Elmax at about 61 HRC sits above MagnaCut at the same hardness. MagnaCut can be run harder: Crucible's aim range is 60 to 63 HRC and its CATRA table lists 135% of 440C at 62.5 HRC, a little above S35VN at 130%. Thomas's own CATRA tests found MagnaCut matches S35VN. In rope cutting that he reports, a 62.5 HRC MagnaCut knife made 45 cuts against 40 for S30V at 61 HRC and 60 for S90V.
Wear is only one way an edge ends. Thomas points out that edges also fail by deformation, chipping and corrosion, which is where MagnaCut's toughness and rust resistance pay back. He calls MagnaCut very well suited to the 62 to 64 HRC range of Japanese kitchen knives, and says high toughness is what allows thinner, more acute edges without chipping.
Elmax has 18% chromium and MagnaCut 10.7%. Why does MagnaCut rust less?
What protects a blade is chromium dissolved in the steel, not the chromium on the datasheet. Elmax's high carbon ties a large share of its chromium up in carbides, and Thomas notes that carbides leave chromium-poor zones around them. Crucible's MagnaCut design eliminates chromium carbide, with niobium and vanadium carbides taking the carbon instead, so its 10.7% stays in solution. In Thomas's 72-hour 1% saltwater spray test MagnaCut showed no rust and Elmax showed rust spots. His ratings are 9.5 against 8.
Neither is in the class Thomas calls saltwater steels, LC200N and Vanax, both rated 10. In a harsher 3.5% saltwater retest he found MagnaCut on the border: fine for occasional saltwater exposure, not for a diving knife. Crucible adds one heat-treat caution, that tempering MagnaCut above 750°F reduces its corrosion resistance.
Which one is easier to heat treat?
MagnaCut, on the published recipes. Crucible's: preheat to 1550–1600°F, austenitize at 2050°F, quench to below 125°F (plate, air or positive-pressure gas; or salt or interrupted oil to about 1000°F, then air), then temper twice for at least 2 hours at 350°F. A cold treatment is optional. The aim is 60 to 63 HRC. Crucible's table lists 61.5 HRC from this recipe after a plate or oil quench and 62 HRC with dry ice or liquid nitrogen, and Thomas reports around 61 to 62.5 HRC. Harder results use a different cycle: with a 300°F temper the same table gives 62.5 and 63 HRC, and its 64 to 65 HRC cells all use a 2100 to 2200°F austenitize and a cold treatment, mostly with a 300°F temper (64 HRC at 2200°F also appears with a 350°F temper and liquid nitrogen or dry ice).
Uddeholm's Elmax heat treatment guideline (revised August 2024): preheat in steps at 1200°F and 1550°F, austenitize at 1920 to 2010°F (1980°F normally) for at least 30 minutes and at most 1 hour, quench in positive-pressure gas, salt or oil, and temper at least twice for a minimum of 2 hours. Uddeholm's datasheet prefers tempering at 480°F (250°C) or higher and allows 350°F only in exceptional cases, for small simple parts where toughness matters less. The guideline lists 56 to 58 HRC for the 480°F and 980°F tempers and expects a cryogenic treatment to add 1 to 2 HRC; the data sheet lists 60 HRC before tempering after a 1920°F austenitize and 61 HRC after 1980°F, which are as-quenched figures, not finished hardness. Nothing in Uddeholm's tables goes above 58 HRC after tempering, but the cold treatment is part of the guideline: by our arithmetic, adding its 1 to 2 HRC gives about 57 to 60 HRC for a cold-treated Elmax, a sum Uddeholm does not itself print. Without a cold treatment, the data sheet's tempering graph reads about 58 to 59 HRC at a 390°F temper and about 60 near 210°F (2010°F austenitize, small samples); the first is below the 480°F Uddeholm prefers (it allows 350°F only in exceptional cases), and the second is below the 350°F minimum its data sheet gives. We have no cycle to cite for the Elmax at about 61 HRC in Thomas's CATRA chart above, so for a knife quoted at 60 HRC or more, ask which cycle was used and confirm the hardness with a test.
Two documented reasons MagnaCut is called forgiving. Crucible allows austenitizing anywhere from 1950 to 2200°F (Thomas used hold times from 30 minutes at 1950°F down to 5 minutes at 2200°F), and Thomas found hardness nearly the same with or without a cold treatment up to 2050°F, which means retained austenite stays low. A vacuum furnace with a 2 bar gas quench came out only 0.5 to 1 HRC under plate or oil quenching, so a heat-treat service gets close to what you get at home. Thomas's January 2026 tests of Erasteel-made MagnaCut found better toughness at a 2150°F austenitize, about 2.5 HRC harder at the same toughness; Crucible's 2050°F stays the datasheet recommendation. For the stages themselves see the complete heat treating guide and plate quenching explained.
Which one grinds and sharpens easier?
Call it even until someone tests them head to head; neither has a standardized grindability test. For MagnaCut, Thomas relies on knifemaker reports. Matt Gregory and Shawn Houston found it grinds and finishes easier than S35VN or S45VN. Gregory found it easier than CPM-154 until about 240 grit, where the vanadium and niobium carbides start to show. Devin Thomas sharpened it well even on aluminum-oxide Shapton Glass stones. Crucible rates annealed MagnaCut easier to machine than CPM 20CV and S30V. For Elmax, Uddeholm lists excellent polishability among its characteristics. Crucible names SG-type alumina or CBN as the best-performing grinding-wheel abrasives on its CPM steels.
The Torus guides cover belts and technique for each: grinding and sharpening MagnaCut and grinding and sharpening Elmax.
Is MagnaCut still being made now that Crucible is gone?
Yes. Thomas reported Crucible's bankruptcy on January 6, 2025. By January 12, 2026 he wrote that Crucible no longer exists, that Erasteel bought its trademarks, and that Niagara Specialty Metals kept the exclusive right to buy MagnaCut ingots and sell the steel to knifemakers and knife companies. Erasteel-made MagnaCut showed no rust spots in his 1% saltwater test, a very similar hardening response, and significantly higher toughness than the Crucible original. He concluded it matches or exceeds the Crucible version and says he will keep monitoring it. Ask your supplier which mill melted the bar you are buying.
What if I want Elmax's wear resistance with MagnaCut's rust resistance?
Thomas's answer is MagnaMax, a higher-carbon relative of MagnaCut. In his January 19, 2026 article he put its carbide volume at about 16%, roughly double MagnaCut's, with edge retention matching K390 and Vanadis 8, toughness similar to S35VN, and no rust spots in his 1% saltwater test. He expected wide release in the second quarter of 2026 and said heat treatment recommendations were still being worked out, so check Niagara's current stock and datasheet before designing around it.
Which one to pick
- MagnaCut if the knife will be hit, twisted, used wet or ground thin: toughness 7 against 4, corrosion 9.5 against 8, and a recipe that lands at 61 to 62.5 HRC.
- Elmax if you want the extra slicing life at equal hardness, already run a tested Elmax recipe or use a heat-treat service that does, and the knife will not see lateral stress.
- Neither if you need saltwater duty (look at LC200N or Vanax) or much higher wear resistance (S90V is rated 9 for edge retention, and MagnaMax is built for it).
More matchups: MagnaCut vs CPM 20CV, CPM 20CV vs Elmax, Elmax vs CPM S35VN and MagnaCut vs LC200N. Full references: MagnaCut and Elmax.
Sources: Crucible Industries, CPM MagnaCut data sheet, as published by Niagara Specialty Metals (nsm-ny.com/cpm-magnacut-data-sheet). Uddeholm Elmax SuperClean data sheet, edition 10, March 2023 (uddeholm.com) and Uddeholm Elmax Heat Treatment Guidelines, revised August 15, 2024 (uddeholm.com). Larrin Thomas, Knife Steel Nerds: CPM MagnaCut, The Next Breakthrough in Knife Steel (March 25, 2021); Knife Steels Rated by a Metallurgist (October 19, 2021, updated June 16, 2025); Crucible Steel is Bankrupt! What is Next for MagnaCut? (January 6, 2025); Testing Erasteel MagnaCut vs Crucible Original (January 12, 2026); MagnaMax Is Here (January 19, 2026). Crucible and Uddeholm figures are manufacturer data; Thomas's tests are his own, and he designed MagnaCut.