
Fantasy Blades in Real Steel: The Maker’s Field Guide
Every fictional blade is a real design brief with the physics turned off. Turn the physics back on and something interesting happens: the analysis becomes…

Fantasy & Fiction Blades
Sanderson's no-metal design brief taken seriously: real obsidian edge physics, why Vin's daggers would work and break, and koloss sword math.
2 min readWritten by Rich LinvilleFree to read
Brandon Sanderson handed his world’s assassins a genuinely great materials-engineering problem: Allomancers can sense and violently manipulate metal, so the deadliest people in the Final Empire fight with glass and obsidian daggers, wooden shields and stone-tipped spears. Fans on the forums have argued the practicalities for years — Vin’s move from glass to obsidian daggers gets its own threads — and the argument is worth having, because the real materials science is stranger than the fiction.
The part fiction does not exaggerate: a conchoidally fractured obsidian edge is sharper than anything a steel blade can hold — the apex thins toward molecular scale, which is why obsidian scalpels have seen real use in modern surgery for ultra-fine incisions. Flint-knapped edges armed most of human history, and the Aztec macuahuitl — a wooden sword edged with obsidian blades — reportedly did horrific work against Spanish steel. As a pure CUTTING material, volcanic glass needs no fantasy assistance.

The other half of the physics: glass and obsidian have effectively zero fracture toughness — the hardness-toughness curve’s brutal far end. No flex, no edge-on-edge contact, no prying, no lateral load: any of them shatters the blade, which is why history’s obsidian weapons were slashers with replaceable edges, never fencing tools. Sanderson plays this fair — his glass-dagger fighters stab and slice soft targets and avoid parries — and the fan-debated glass-to-obsidian switch tracks a real distinction too: manufactured glass is homogeneous and predictable; good obsidian is the superior knapping material with the sharper practical edge. A duel between obsidian daggers and a steel EDC blade ends with the steel intact and the obsidian in pieces — after the obsidian cut deeper on the first pass.

At the other extreme, the koloss carry crude iron greatswords sized for ten-foot monsters, and normal humans in the books simply cannot use them — which is the correct physics. Run the mass math from the impossible-swords guide: scale a 6-pound greatsword to koloss dimensions and you are carrying a blade in the dozens-of-pounds class, swingable only with superhuman strength — which is exactly what pewter-burning provides. Sanderson’s reputation for hard-magic consistency survives the calculator, which is more than most franchises manage.

The no-metal brief is a fun real commission: knapped obsidian or glass blades with wood, antler or micarta furniture — knapping is its own venerable craft, adjacent to ours the way leatherwork is — sold as display and cutting-demo pieces with the fragility stated plainly. The steel maker’s version: an inspired-by dagger in blackened 26C3 or W2 with an obsidian-dark etched finish per Blade Finishes — the Mistborn mood, none of the shatter. Either way the fan learns the real lesson: every material choice is a trade, and the Final Empire’s assassins were making the same trades a maker weighs at the steel rack.

Keep reading
Three more from the same bench.

Every fictional blade is a real design brief with the physics turned off. Turn the physics back on and something interesting happens: the analysis becomes…

Heat treat recipes and steel spec sheets both cite a target hardness on the Rockwell C scale, but the number by itself doesn’t explain why that specific…

Big blades live on impact, and impact rewrites the geometry rules: the edge is a wedge under shock load, balance is a cutting spec, and…
Same bench
I machine the parts, hand-assemble, track and test Torus grinders in Sterling, Illinois. Most orders ship in seven to ten business days from time of order.

Current dual-axis platform with a fiber-laser-cut 6061 chassis and single-knob tracking.

Current dual-axis platform with a steel chassis, more mass and less vibration.
These are the last Nebula chassis available until the next release. Once this run sells out, availability pauses until the next run is ready.
Next release: 10 more chassis expected Nov 17–Nov 24 (3–4 weeks from Oct 27).

Prior-design aluminum chassis, 90-degree tilt and 1.5-inch tooling arms.

One-man shop
I answer my own email. Tell me the steel, the machine and what it is doing, and I will tell you what I would try next.